Film Review: Brothers
“Brothers” is a borderline drama, a remake spawned from the 2004 Danish film “Brødre”. (Which I haven’t seen so this will be slightly biased) Taking place in both Afghanistan and Denmark the movie follows the lives of brothers Sam (Tobey Maquire) and Tommy Cahill (Jake Gyllenhaal). Tommy is an ex-con trying to find his footing in the family. At times he finds himself going head to head with his father who feels he’s shamed the family having served time in jail. Sam on the other hand has a wife and two daughters he’s also being deployed to Afghanistan.
While in Afghanistan a helicopter transporting Sam and his troop was shot down and Sam was presumed dead. Little did they know Sam was alive and being held prisoner by the enemy. The movie then follows Sam and his struggle to get back to his family. While Tommy spends time with Sam’s children helping them cope with their fathers passing and building a fatherly bond with the girls.
When Sam finally returns home he’s merely the shell of the man he was before. The war has transformed him into a jealous, paranoid and violent man. He’s lost the ability to nurture his children and his trust for his wife and brother has disappeared.
I feel like we were mislead in the commercial, I assumed that this movie would be filled with a lot more drama. I hate to say the best scenes had to be the ones where Sam’s being held prisoner. We felt how coldhearted his captors were and saw that a man would do anything for his family. In that same breath we saw how much of a coward Sam really was, he turned out to have a lot in common with the enemy.
This movie was just barely melodrama. At some point Isabelle (Bailee Madison) carries the movie and is a bit more animated than her co-stars. When the movie finally opens up with Sam exploding with the paranoia of Tommy and Grace’s (Natalie Portman) possible relationship the movie is practically over. Again I’ve never seen “Brødre” so I really can’t say if this is a better film or even a decent remake of that film. What I do know is this really isn’t worth the time to go and see. The viewer is constantly toyed with the entire time. Sitting in agony praying that something exciting happens we’d be happy if Sam really died at some point because watching him behave in such a manor was just entirely too awkward. Save your money.
